lossless-cut/issues.md

FAQ

Please read this first:

• Q: Can LosslessCut crop, resize, stretch, mirror/flip, overlay text/images, watermark, blur, redact, reduce quality/re-encode, create GIF, slideshow, burn subtitles, color grading, fade/transition between video clips, fade/combine/mix/merge audio tracks or change audio volume?
  • A: No, these are all lossy operations (meaning you have to re-encode the file), but in the future I may start to implement such features. See #372. Related: #643.
• Q: Is there a keyboard shortcut to do X?
  • A: First check the Keyboard shortcuts dialog. If you cannot find your shortcut there, see this issue.
• Q: Can LosslessCut do the same batch conversion operation on multiple files?
  • A: Probably not, but you can probably do it! See here.
• Q: Can LosslessCut be automated using a CLI or API or do external post-processing?
  • A: While it was never designed for advanced batching/automation, it does have a basic CLI and a HTTP API. More info: #980 #868.
• Q: How to cut away a middle part of a video?
  • A: Enable "advanced view" and then click the Yin Yang symbol. It will invert the segments.
• Q: When will you implement feature X?
  • A: I have limited time and I have a lot of projects to work on, so I cannot promise any timeline. I will usually prioritize the issues with the most likes, see here for a list of the most popular issues.
• Q: Is LosslessCut a portable app? Where is application data, settings and temp files stored?
  • A: See LosslessCut is not a portable app. See Installation and files.
• Q: Can I export and replace the input file in-place?
  • A: No, but you can export and automatically delete the input file.
• Q: Can you publish through winget, Flatpak, Docker or other software mangers?
  • A: In general I don't want to maintain more build systems, but I could be open to linking to externally maintained build systems.

App Stores and GitHub difference

LosslessCut version in the App Stores is often a few versions behind the latest GitHub version, because I want to be sure that the new versions work perfectly before releasing in the App Stores. The GitHub version will contain new, untested features and may contain some bugs (even in existing functionality). I consider the newest GitHub versions to be a public "beta" test. Then, once I'm sure that the new version works well, I will release it in the App Stores as well to give a frictionless as possible experience for customers. They have exactly the same in-app features, except for a few platform limitations: Apple doesn't allow opening VOB files with App Store apps. Apple App Store apps run in a sandbox, and therefore need to prompt for output directory before allowing writing files.

Primer: Video & audio formats vs. codecs

Here's a little primer about video and audio formats for those not familiar. A common mistake when dealing with audio and video files, is to confuse formats, codecs, and file names. In short: A file's media format is a container that holds one or more codecs (audio/video/subtitle) inside of it. For example .mov is a container format, and H265/HEVC is a codec. Some formats support only a few codecs inside of them, while others support more codecs. The most common formats are MP4/MOV (often .mp4,.mov,.m4a) and Matroska (often .mkv,.mka). Example: If you have a file named My video.mp4, this file most likely (but not necessarily) has the format MP4. Note that the extension of a file (in this case .mp4) doesn't really mean anything, and the file could in reality for example have the MOV format, or the extension could be .txt. Inside My video.mp4 there are multiple tracks/streams, each with their own codec. In this example, let's say that it contains one H264 track and one AAC track. In LosslessCut you can view and add/delete/modify these tracks.

Remuxing: If you change the output format in LosslessCut and export a file, you are remuxing the tracks/codecs into a different container format. When you do this, the operation is in theory lossless, meaning you will not lose any codec data and the different tracks will remain exactly the same, even though the format is now different (but some format metadata might get lost due to incompatibilities between container formats). There are limitations: Some popular codecs like VP8 or VP9 are not supported in popular formats like MP4, and some popular formats like Matroska (.mkv) are not natively supported in popular video players like iPhone or QuickTime.

If you want to reduce the size of a file using LosslessCut you have to "get rid of" something, either:

• Reduce the duration of the file (cut off start/end)
• Remove one or more tracks/streams (e.g. remove an audio track that you don't need) Other than that you it's not possible convert a file losslessly to reduce its size, unless you re-encode and lose quality. For that, I recommend using a different tool like e.g. HandBrake.

Here is a great introduction to audio/video: howvideo.works.

Common / known issues & troubleshooting

The exported video has a problem

If the video exports successfully without any error from LosslessCut, but it does not look as expected when playing back, please try this:

• Try both with Keyframe cut mode on and off (do not use Smart Cut if you have any problem).
• Disable unnecessary tracks from the Tracks panel. First try to disable all tracks except the main track (e.g. video) and if that succeeds, then work your way by enabling more tracks and see which one is causing the problem. Sometimes LosslessCut (ffmpeg) is unable to cut certain tracks at all, and this could lead to a strange output (e.g. wrong output duration or black parts).
• Select a different output format (matroska and mov support a lot of codecs.)
• Try the same operation with a different file (same codec or different codec) and see whether it's a problem with just that one particular file.
• Enable the Experimental Flag under Settings before trying again.

Cutting times are not accurate

Each segment's start cut time normally (but not always) will be "rounded" to the nearest previous keyframe. This means that you often have to move the start cut time to few frames after the desired keyframe.

• Lossless cutting is not an exact science. For some files, it just works. For others, you may need to trial and error to get the best cut. See #330
• Your mileage may vary when it comes to Keyframe cut mode. Most common video files need Keyframe cut enabled, but you may need to try both values. ffmpeg also has documentation about these two seek/cut modes. In ffmpeg, Keyframe cut corresponds to -ss before -i.
• Try to change avoid_negative_ts (in export options).
• Try also to set the start-cutpoint a few frames before or after the nearest keyframe (may also solve audio sync issues).
• You may try to enable the new "Smart cut" mode to allow cutting between keyframes. However it is very experimental and may not work for many files.
• Currently, the only way to review the exported file (to check the actual cutpoints) is to run the export (possibly with only one segment enabled to speed up) and then manually check the output file. See also #1887

Starts from wrong keyframe

For some files, when you place segment start cutpoints at keyframes, and you export, it will instead cut from the keyframe before the keyframe that you wanted. This is because with some videos, ffmpeg struggles to find the nearest previous keyframe, see #1216. To workaround this, you can try to shift your segments' start-cutpoints forward by a few frames, so that ffmpeg correctly cuts from the previous keyframe. You can also enable the Export Option "Shift all start times" by +1, +2, +3 frames or so.

• Menu: "Edit" -> "Segments" -> "Shift all segments on timeline"
• Enter 00:00:00.200 (or a larger value if it doesn't help)
• When asked about Start or End timestamps, Select Start

This will effectively shift all start times of segments by 6 frames (6/30=0.2 for 30fps video).

Cut file has same length as input

If you cut a file, but the duration of the exported file is the same as input file's duration, try to disable all tracks except for the video track and see if that helps. Sometimes a file contains some tracks that LosslessCut is unable to cut. It will then leave them as is, while cutting the other tracks. This may lead to incorrect output duration. Try also changing avoid_negative_ts (in export options).

If you are trying to cut a FLAC file but your output has the same duration as input, you might have run into this ffmpeg limitation.

Merge / concat results in corrupt or broken parts

This can happen when trying to merge files that are not compatible. Make sure they have the exact same codec parameters before merging. If you are sure they are the same, you can try to first running each of the files separately through LosslessCut before merging the outputs:

1. First open each file separately and just export without cutting anything

• Changing format to mp4 is known to fix certain issues like Non-monotonous DTS in output stream
• If you're seeing incorrect output duration, sped up or slowed down segments, then changing format to TS is known to give the files a common timebase, which sometimes makes it possible to merge them.

3. Then merge the exported files.

Doing this first might "clean up" certain parameters in the files, to make them more compatible for merging. If this doesn't work, you can also try to change avoid_negative_ts (in export options). Also try to disable most tracks (see above). If this doesn't resolve the issue, then it probably means that you're hitting a bug or limitation in FFmpeg with the particular file that you're cutting/merging. Unfortunately there's not much to do other than trying different output settings, different cut time or waiting for improvements in FFmpeg.

Smart cut not working

Smart cut is experimental, so don't expect too much. But if you're having problems, check out this issue.

• If Smart cut gives you repeated (duplicate) segments, you can try to enable the Export Option "Shift all start times".
• Sometimes it helps to convert (remux) your videos to mp4 first (e.g. from mkv) using LosslessCut, before smart cutting them.

MP4/MOV issues

MP4 and MOV are technically almost the same format. Sometimes files have the extension .mp4 but are in reality the MOV format (and vice versa). MOV tends to be more lenient in which codecs it supports. FFmpeg has problems exporting some MP4 files as MP4, so MOV needs to be selected instead. Unfortunately I don't know any way to fix this. Sometimes certain players are not able to play back certain exported .mov files (Adobe Premiere 👀). You can try to rename the exported MOV file extension to .mp4 and see if it helps. Or vice versa, rename an exported MP4 file to .mov.

Output file name is missing characters (Chinese, accents etc)

If the output file name has special characters that get replaced by underscore (_), try to turn off "Sanitize" in the "Output file names" editor in the "Export options" dialog. Note that this will cause special characters like / to be preserved. Some characters are not supported in some operating systems, so be careful. using / or \ can be used to create a folder structure from your segments when exported.

Linux specific issues

• If you get an error like FATAL:setuid_sandbox_host.cc(157)] The SUID sandbox helper binary was found, but is not configured correctly. Rather than run without sandboxing I'm aborting now., try to run it as ./lossless-cut --no-sandbox. See #258
• Hardware accelerated HEVC playback

If you have an issue with the Snap or Flatpak version of LosslessCut, try instead the GitHub downloads. I cannot provide support for the Flatpak version because is not maintained by me.

Windows specific issues

• I get an error/crash immediately when starting up LosslessCut
  • Try to disable your anti-virus or whitelist LosslessCut. See #18 #1114
• Completely white window when starting up?
  • Try to run with --disable-gpu - See 781.
• How to uninstall LosslessCut?
  • There is no installer. Just delete the folder. More info.
• Preview of H265/HEVC files is completely black, corrupted or just won't play back?
  • This probably means that Chromium (which LosslessCut uses for playback) doesn't support your particular file (maybe it's 10-bit). #2228, #1767
  • Go to settings and disable "Hardware HEVC decoding".
  • Use FFmpeg-assisted software decoding playback by going to File -> Convert to supported format
• Video preview playback slow, stuttering, flickering inside LosslessCut (NVIDIA)
  • See #922 #1904 #1915 #922 #2083
• Why no .exe/.zip/.appx downloads?
  • I decided to stop distributing exe/zip and instead just 7zip, due to the problems that the (self-extracting) exe was causing and the large size of .zip files. appx is unsigned and does not work.
• I'm getting a KERNEL32.dll error
  • It's probably because you're running Windows 7, 8 or 8.1 which is no longer supported.

Known limitations

• Undo/redo segments doesn't work through the top menu. This is a known issue that I don't know how to fix. Please use the keyboard shortcuts instead (CTRL/CMD+Z and CTRL+Y / CMD+SHIFT+Z).

Low quality / blurry playback

Some formats or codecs are not natively supported, so they will play back with a lower quality. You may convert these files to a supported codec from the File menu, see #88.

MPEG TS / MTS

MPEG TS (.mts/.ts) files have a tendency to be a bit problematic. It may help to first remux them to another format like MP4/MKV. Then you can open the MP4/MKV file an work on that. Also disable non-needed tracks. In LosslessCut you can remux files by simply opening them, select a different output format, and export without editing the timeline (segments).

EXIF / metadata

It is a known problem that FFmpeg will not always preserve metadata correctly. More info #1027. Some metadata can be preserved (see Export Options dialog), but it doesn't always output compliant files, so use it carefully. Alternatively you can use exiftool after exporting with LosslessCut to transfer metadata, for example:

exiftool -tagsFromFile Original-Source-File.mp4 -all:all -overwrite_original Exported-From-LosslessCut.mp4

Proprietary data tracks list

When exporting, LosslessCut may be unable to process certain proprietary tracks. For example tmcd, fdsc and gpmd added by GoPro. These can however be losslessly exported to separate files if you want to keep this data for later.

Multiple LosslessCut instances

By default, only a single running instance of LosslessCut is allowed. If you start a new LosslessCut instance from the command line, it will instead pass the list of files onto the already running instance. You can override this behavior inside settings Note that this is (experimental), because Electron doesn't seem to support this. More info #1641

Rotation and merging

A video’s rotation is just metadata stored in its file. A file can only have a single rotation across the whole file, so if you have two video files and you rotate only one file and then concatenate them, there will be only one output rotation.

Still cannot find an answer?

If any other problem please search for existing issues before you ask a question here on GitHub. You can check the developer tools for any errors or clues. Menu: Tools -> Toggle Developer Tools. Also you are welcome to hang out on Discord 🤗