Describe what your pull request does. If appropriate, add GIFs or images
showing the before and after.
### Change Type
- [x] `sdk` — Changes the tldraw SDK
- [x] `galaxy brain` — Architectural changes
### Test Plan
1. Add a step-by-step description of how to test your PR here.
2.
- [ ] Unit Tests
- [ ] End to end tests
### Release Notes
#### BREAKING CHANGES
- The `Migrations` type is now called `LegacyMigrations`.
- The serialized schema format (e.g. returned by
`StoreSchema.serialize()` and `Store.getSnapshot()`) has changed. You
don't need to do anything about it unless you were reading data directly
from the schema for some reason. In which case it'd be best to avoid
that in the future! We have no plans to change the schema format again
(this time was traumatic enough) but you never know.
- `compareRecordVersions` and the `RecordVersion` type have both
disappeared. There is no replacement. These were public by mistake
anyway, so hopefully nobody had been using it.
- `compareSchemas` is a bit less useful now. Our migrations system has
become a little fuzzy to allow for simpler UX when adding/removing
custom extensions and 3rd party dependencies, and as a result we can no
longer compare serialized schemas in any rigorous manner. You can rely
on this function to return `0` if the schemas are the same. Otherwise it
will return `-1` if the schema on the right _seems_ to be newer than the
schema on the left, but it cannot guarantee that in situations where
migration sequences have been removed over time (e.g. if you remove one
of the builtin tldraw shapes).
Generally speaking, the best way to check schema compatibility now is to
call `store.schema.getMigrationsSince(persistedSchema)`. This will throw
an error if there is no upgrade path from the `persistedSchema` to the
current version.
- `defineMigrations` has been deprecated and will be removed in a future
release. For upgrade instructions see
https://tldraw.dev/docs/persistence#Updating-legacy-shape-migrations-defineMigrations
- `migrate` has been removed. Nobody should have been using this but if
you were you'll need to find an alternative. For migrating tldraw data,
you should stick to using `schema.migrateStoreSnapshot` and, if you are
building a nuanced sync engine that supports some amount of backwards
compatibility, also feel free to use `schema.migratePersistedRecord`.
- the `Migration` type has changed. If you need the old one for some
reason it has been renamed to `LegacyMigration`. It will be removed in a
future release.
- the `Migrations` type has been renamed to `LegacyMigrations` and will
be removed in a future release.
- the `SerializedSchema` type has been augmented. If you need the old
version specifically you can use `SerializedSchemaV1`
---------
Co-authored-by: Steve Ruiz <steveruizok@gmail.com>
Comparing different culling optimizations:
https://github.com/tldraw/tldraw/assets/2523721/0b3b8b42-ed70-45b7-bf83-41023c36a563
I think we should go with the `display: none` + showing the skeleteon.
The way it works is:
- We now add a sibling to the shape wrapper div which serves as the
skeleton for the culled shapes.
- Only one of the two divs (shape wrapper and skeleton div) is
displayed. The other one is using `display: none` to improve
performance.
### Change Type
<!-- ❗ Please select a 'Scope' label ❗️ -->
- [ ] `sdk` — Changes the tldraw SDK
- [ ] `dotcom` — Changes the tldraw.com web app
- [ ] `docs` — Changes to the documentation, examples, or templates.
- [ ] `vs code` — Changes to the vscode plugin
- [x] `internal` — Does not affect user-facing stuff
<!-- ❗ Please select a 'Type' label ❗️ -->
- [ ] `bugfix` — Bug fix
- [ ] `feature` — New feature
- [x] `improvement` — Improving existing features
- [ ] `chore` — Updating dependencies, other boring stuff
- [ ] `galaxy brain` — Architectural changes
- [ ] `tests` — Changes to any test code
- [ ] `tools` — Changes to infrastructure, CI, internal scripts,
debugging tools, etc.
- [ ] `dunno` — I don't know
- Improve performance of culled shapes by using `display: none`.
---------
Co-authored-by: Steve Ruiz <steveruizok@gmail.com>
## Migration path
1. If any of your shapes implement `toSvg` for exports, you'll need to
replace your implementation with a new version that returns JSX (it's a
react component) instead of manually constructing SVG DOM nodes
2. `editor.getSvg` is deprecated. It still works, but will be going away
in a future release. If you still need SVGs as DOM elements rather than
strings, use `new DOMParser().parseFromString(svgString,
'image/svg+xml').firstElementChild`
## The change in detail
At the moment, our SVG exports very carefully try to recreate the
visuals of our shapes by manually constructing SVG DOM nodes. On its own
this is really painful, but it also results in a lot of duplicated logic
between the `component` and `getSvg` methods of shape utils.
In #3020, we looked at using string concatenation & DOMParser to make
this a bit less painful. This works, but requires specifying namespaces
everywhere, is still pretty painful (no syntax highlighting or
formatting), and still results in all that duplicated logic.
I briefly experimented with creating my own version of the javascript
language that let you embed XML like syntax directly. I was going to
call it EXTREME JAVASCRIPT or XJS for short, but then I noticed that we
already wrote the whole of tldraw in this thing called react and a (imo
much worse named) version of the javascript xml thing already existed.
Given the entire library already depends on react, what would it look
like if we just used react directly for these exports? Turns out things
get a lot simpler! Take a look at lmk what you think
This diff was intended as a proof of concept, but is actually pretty
close to being landable. The main thing is that here, I've deliberately
leant into this being a big breaking change to see just how much code we
could delete (turns out: lots). We could if we wanted to make this
without making it a breaking change at all, but it would add back a lot
of complexity on our side and run a fair bit slower
---------
Co-authored-by: huppy-bot[bot] <128400622+huppy-bot[bot]@users.noreply.github.com>
This diff adds a self-snapping API for handles. Self-snapping is used
when a shape's handles want to snap to the shape itself. By default,
this isn't allowed because moving the handle might move the snap point,
which creates a janky user experience.
Now, shapes can return customised versions of their normal handle
snapping geometry in these cases. As a bonus, line shapes now snap to
other handles on their own line!
### Change Type
- [x] `minor` — New feature
### Test Plan
1. Line handles should snap to other handles on the same line when
holding command
- [x] Unit Tests
### Release Notes
- Line handles now snap to other handles on the same line when holding
command
---------
Co-authored-by: Steve Ruiz <steveruizok@gmail.com>
This diff adds an API for customising our existing snap types. These
are:
1. Bound snapping. When translating or resizing a shape, it'll snap to
certain key points on the bounds of particular shapes. Previously, these
were hard-coded to the corners and center of the bounding box of the
shape. Now, a shape can bring its own (e.g. a triangle may add snapping
for its 3 corners, and it's centroid rather than bounding box center.
2. Handle outline snapping. When dragging a handle, it'll snap to the
outline of other shapes geometry. Now, shapes can return different
geometry for this sort of snapping if they like.
Each of these is customised through a method on `ShapeUtil`:
`getBoundsSnapGeometry` and `getHandleSnapGeometry`. These return
interfaces describing the different geometry that can be snapped to in
both these cases. Currently, each returns an object with a single
property, but there are more types of snapping coming in follow-up PRs.
When reviewing this PR, start with the definitions of
`BoundsSnapGeometry` in `BoundsSnaps.ts` and `HandleSnapGeometry` in
`HandleSnaps.ts`
This doesn't add point snapping - i'll add that in a follow-up! It'll be
customisable with the `getHandleSnapGeometry` API.
Fixes TLD-2197
This PR is part of a series - please don't merge it until the things
before it have landed!
1. #2827
4. #2831
5. #2793 (you are here)
6. #2841
7. #2845
### Change Type
- [x] `minor` — New feature
[^1]: publishes a `patch` release, for devDependencies use `internal`
[^2]: will not publish a new version
### Test Plan
- [x] Unit Tests
### Release Notes
- Add `ShapeUtil.getSnapInfo` for customising shape snaps.
This is a followup on the arrows work.
- allow labels to go to the ends if no arrowhead is present
- avoid using / overloading TLHandle and use a new PointingLabel state
to specifically address label movement
- removes the feature flag to launch this feature!
### Change Type
- [x] `patch` — Bug fix
### Release Notes
- Arrow labels: provide more polish on label placement
---------
Co-authored-by: Steve Ruiz <steveruizok@gmail.com>
This adds the ability to drag the label on an arrow to a different
location within the line segment/arc.
https://github.com/tldraw/tldraw/assets/469604/dbd2ee35-bebc-48d6-b8ee-fcf12ce91fa5
- A lot of the complexity lay in ensuring a fixed distance from the ends
of the arrowheads.
- I added a new type of handle `text-adjust` that makes the text box the
very handle itself.
- I added a `ARROW_HANDLES` enum - we should use more enums!
- The bulk of the changes are in ArrowShapeUtil — check that out in
particular obviously :)
Along the way, I tried to improve a couple spots as I touched them:
- added some more documentation to Vec.ts because some of the functions
in there were obscure/new to me. (at least the naming, hah)
- added `getPointOnCircle` which was being done in a couple places
independently and refactored those places.
### Questions
- the `getPointOnCircle` API changed. Is this considered breaking and/or
should I leave the signature the same? Wasn't sure if it was a big deal
or not.
- I made `labelPosition` in the schema always but I guess it could have
been optional? Lemme know if there's a preference.
- Any feedback on tests? Happy to expand those if necessary.
### Change Type
- [ ] `patch` — Bug fix
- [x] `minor` — New feature
- [ ] `major` — Breaking change
- [ ] `dependencies` — Changes to package dependencies[^1]
- [ ] `documentation` — Changes to the documentation only[^2]
- [ ] `tests` — Changes to any test code only[^2]
- [ ] `internal` — Any other changes that don't affect the published
package[^2]
- [ ] I don't know
[^1]: publishes a `patch` release, for devDependencies use `internal`
[^2]: will not publish a new version
### Test Plan
1. For arrow in [straightArrow, curvedArrow] test the following:
a. Label in the middle
b. Label at both ends of the arrow
c. Test arrows in different directions
d. Rotating the endpoints and seeing that the label stays at the end of
the arrow at a fixed width.
e. Test different stroke widths.
f. Test with different arrowheads.
2. Also, test arcs that are more circle like than arc-like.
- [x] Unit Tests
- [ ] End to end tests
### Release Notes
- Adds ability to change label position on arrows.
---------
Co-authored-by: Steve Ruiz <steveruizok@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: alex <alex@dytry.ch>
fix typo in hideRotateHandle method
### Change Type
- [ ] `patch` — Bug fix
- [ ] `minor` — New feature
- [ ] `major` — Breaking change
- [ ] `dependencies` — Changes to package dependencies[^1]
- [x] `documentation` — Changes to the documentation only[^2]
- [ ] `tests` — Changes to any test code only[^2]
- [ ] `internal` — Any other changes that don't affect the published
package[^2]
- [ ] I don't know
[^1]: publishes a `patch` release, for devDependencies use `internal`
[^2]: will not publish a new version
### Test Plan
1. Add a step-by-step description of how to test your PR here.
2.
- [ ] Unit Tests
- [ ] End to end tests
### Release Notes
- fix typo in hideRotateHandle method
This PR adds the docs app back into the tldraw monorepo.
## Deploying
We'll want to update our deploy script to update the SOURCE_SHA to the
newest release sha... and then deploy the docs pulling api.json files
from that release. We _could_ update the docs on every push to main, but
we don't have to unless something has changed. Right now there's no
automated deployments from this repo.
## Side effects
To make this one work, I needed to update the lock file. This might be
ok (new year new lock file), and everything builds as expected, though
we may want to spend some time with our scripts to be sure that things
are all good.
I also updated our prettier installation, which decided to add trailing
commas to every generic type. Which is, I suppose, [correct
behavior](https://github.com/prettier/prettier-vscode/issues/955)? But
that caused diffs in every file, which is unfortunate.
### Change Type
- [x] `internal` — Any other changes that don't affect the published
package[^2]
This PR passes the initial shape to the onHandleChange method. It makes
it a bit easier to work with handles in custom shapes.
### Change Type
- [ ] `patch` — Bug fix
- [ ] `minor` — New feature
- [ ] `major` — Breaking change
- [ ] `dependencies` — Changes to package dependencies[^1]
- [ ] `documentation` — Changes to the documentation only[^2]
- [ ] `tests` — Changes to any test code only[^2]
- [x] `internal` — Any other changes that don't affect the published
package[^2]
- [] I don't know
[^1]: publishes a `patch` release, for devDependencies use `internal`
[^2]: will not publish a new version
### Test Plan
- [ ] Unit Tests
- [ ] End to end tests
### Release Notes
- Add a brief release note for your PR here.
This PR prevents certain shapes from being edited while in readonly
mode. It adds `ShapeUtil.canEditInReadOnly` to allow developers to opt
in to editing shapes. It's currently applied only to embed shapes.
### Change Type
- [x] `major`
### Test Plan
1. In a readonly mode, try to edit text / sticky notes / arrow labels
via double click / enter. You should not be able to edit them.
2. Try to edit an embed. You should be able to edit it.
### Release Notes
- Prevent editing text shapes in readonly mode.
This PR fixes a bug introduced with #1751 where pointing the bounds of
rotated selections would not correctly hit the bounds background.
### Change Type
- [x] `patch` — Bug fix
### Test Plan
1. Create a rotated selection.
2. Point into the bounds background
- [x] Unit Tests
This PR is a significant rewrite of our selection / hit testing logic.
It
- replaces our current geometric helpers (`getBounds`, `getOutline`,
`hitTestPoint`, and `hitTestLineSegment`) with a new geometry API
- moves our hit testing entirely to JS using geometry
- improves selection logic, especially around editing shapes, groups and
frames
- fixes many minor selection bugs (e.g. shapes behind frames)
- removes hit-testing DOM elements from ShapeFill etc.
- adds many new tests around selection
- adds new tests around selection
- makes several superficial changes to surface editor APIs
This PR is hard to evaluate. The `selection-omnibus` test suite is
intended to describe all of the selection behavior, however all existing
tests are also either here preserved and passing or (in a few cases
around editing shapes) are modified to reflect the new behavior.
## Geometry
All `ShapeUtils` implement `getGeometry`, which returns a single
geometry primitive (`Geometry2d`). For example:
```ts
class BoxyShapeUtil {
getGeometry(shape: BoxyShape) {
return new Rectangle2d({
width: shape.props.width,
height: shape.props.height,
isFilled: true,
margin: shape.props.strokeWidth
})
}
}
```
This geometric primitive is used for all bounds calculation, hit
testing, intersection with arrows, etc.
There are several geometric primitives that extend `Geometry2d`:
- `Arc2d`
- `Circle2d`
- `CubicBezier2d`
- `CubicSpline2d`
- `Edge2d`
- `Ellipse2d`
- `Group2d`
- `Polygon2d`
- `Rectangle2d`
- `Stadium2d`
For shapes that have more complicated geometric representations, such as
an arrow with a label, the `Group2d` can accept other primitives as its
children.
## Hit testing
Previously, we did all hit testing via events set on shapes and other
elements. In this PR, I've replaced those hit tests with our own
calculation for hit tests in JavaScript. This removed the need for many
DOM elements, such as hit test area borders and fills which only existed
to trigger pointer events.
## Selection
We now support selecting "hollow" shapes by clicking inside of them.
This involves a lot of new logic but it should work intuitively. See
`Editor.getShapeAtPoint` for the (thoroughly commented) implementation.
every sunset is actually the sun hiding in fear and respect of tldraw's
quality of interactions
This PR also fixes several bugs with scribble selection, in particular
around the shift key modifier.
...as well as issues with labels and editing.
There are **over 100 new tests** for selection covering groups, frames,
brushing, scribbling, hovering, and editing. I'll add a few more before
I feel comfortable merging this PR.
## Arrow binding
Using the same "hollow shape" logic as selection, arrow binding is
significantly improved.
a thousand wise men could not improve on this
## Moving focus between editing shapes
Previously, this was handled in the `editing_shapes` state. This is
moved to `useEditableText`, and should generally be considered an
advanced implementation detail on a shape-by-shape basis. This addresses
a bug that I'd never noticed before, but which can be reproduced by
selecting an shape—but not focusing its input—while editing a different
shape. Previously, the new shape became the editing shape but its input
did not focus.
In this PR, you can select a shape by clicking on its edge or body, or
select its input to transfer editing / focus.
tldraw, glorious tldraw
### Change Type
- [x] `major` — Breaking change
### Test Plan
1. Erase shapes
2. Select shapes
3. Calculate their bounding boxes
- [ ] Unit Tests // todo
- [ ] End to end tests // todo
### Release Notes
- [editor] Remove `ShapeUtil.getBounds`, `ShapeUtil.getOutline`,
`ShapeUtil.hitTestPoint`, `ShapeUtil.hitTestLineSegment`
- [editor] Add `ShapeUtil.getGeometry`
- [editor] Add `Editor.getShapeGeometry`
This PR moves code between our packages so that:
- @tldraw/editor is a “core” library with the engine and canvas but no
shapes, tools, or other things
- @tldraw/tldraw contains everything particular to the experience we’ve
built for tldraw
At first look, this might seem like a step away from customization and
configuration, however I believe it greatly increases the configuration
potential of the @tldraw/editor while also providing a more accurate
reflection of what configuration options actually exist for
@tldraw/tldraw.
## Library changes
@tldraw/editor re-exports its dependencies and @tldraw/tldraw re-exports
@tldraw/editor.
- users of @tldraw/editor WITHOUT @tldraw/tldraw should almost always
only import things from @tldraw/editor.
- users of @tldraw/tldraw should almost always only import things from
@tldraw/tldraw.
- @tldraw/polyfills is merged into @tldraw/editor
- @tldraw/indices is merged into @tldraw/editor
- @tldraw/primitives is merged mostly into @tldraw/editor, partially
into @tldraw/tldraw
- @tldraw/file-format is merged into @tldraw/tldraw
- @tldraw/ui is merged into @tldraw/tldraw
Many (many) utils and other code is moved from the editor to tldraw. For
example, embeds now are entirely an feature of @tldraw/tldraw. The only
big chunk of code left in core is related to arrow handling.
## API Changes
The editor can now be used without tldraw's assets. We load them in
@tldraw/tldraw instead, so feel free to use whatever fonts or images or
whatever that you like with the editor.
All tools and shapes (except for the `Group` shape) are moved to
@tldraw/tldraw. This includes the `select` tool.
You should use the editor with at least one tool, however, so you now
also need to send in an `initialState` prop to the Editor /
<TldrawEditor> component indicating which state the editor should begin
in.
The `components` prop now also accepts `SelectionForeground`.
The complex selection component that we use for tldraw is moved to
@tldraw/tldraw. The default component is quite basic but can easily be
replaced via the `components` prop. We pass down our tldraw-flavored
SelectionFg via `components`.
Likewise with the `Scribble` component: the `DefaultScribble` no longer
uses our freehand tech and is a simple path instead. We pass down the
tldraw-flavored scribble via `components`.
The `ExternalContentManager` (`Editor.externalContentManager`) is
removed and replaced with a mapping of types to handlers.
- Register new content handlers with
`Editor.registerExternalContentHandler`.
- Register new asset creation handlers (for files and URLs) with
`Editor.registerExternalAssetHandler`
### Change Type
- [x] `major` — Breaking change
### Test Plan
- [x] Unit Tests
- [x] End to end tests
### Release Notes
- [@tldraw/editor] lots, wip
- [@tldraw/ui] gone, merged to tldraw/tldraw
- [@tldraw/polyfills] gone, merged to tldraw/editor
- [@tldraw/primitives] gone, merged to tldraw/editor / tldraw/tldraw
- [@tldraw/indices] gone, merged to tldraw/editor
- [@tldraw/file-format] gone, merged to tldraw/tldraw
---------
Co-authored-by: alex <alex@dytry.ch>
tldraw-zero themed follow-ups to the styles API added in #1580.
- Removed style related helpers from `ShapeUtil`
- `editor.css` no longer includes the tldraw default color palette.
Instead, a global `DefaultColorPalette` is defined as part of the color
style. If developers wish to cusomise the colors, they can mutate that
global.
- `ShapeUtil.toSvg` no longer takes font/color. Instead, it takes an
"svg export context" that can be used to add `<defs>` to the exported
SVG element. Converting e.g. fonts to inlined data urls is now the
responsibility of the shapes that use them rather than the Editor.
- `usePattern` is not longer a core part of the editor. Instead,
`ShapeUtil` has a `getCanvasSvgDefs` method for returning react
components representing anything a shape needs included in `<defs>` for
the canvas.
- The shape-specific cleanup logic in `setStyle` has been deleted. It
turned out that none of that logic has been running anyway, and instead
the relevant logic lives in shape `onBeforeChange` callbacks already.
### Change Type
- [x] `minor` — New feature
### Test Plan
- [x] Unit Tests
- [x] End to end tests
### Release Notes
--
---------
Co-authored-by: Steve Ruiz <steveruizok@gmail.com>
This PR improves the ergonomics of `ShapeUtil` classes.
### Cached methods
First, I've remove the cached methods (such as `bounds`) from the
`ShapeUtil` class and lifted this to the `Editor` class.
Previously, calling `ShapeUtil.getBounds` would return the un-cached
bounds of a shape, while calling `ShapeUtil.bounds` would return the
cached bounds of a shape. We also had `Editor.getBounds`, which would
call `ShapeUtil.bounds`. It was confusing. The cached methods like
`outline` were also marked with "please don't override", which suggested
the architecture was just wrong.
The only weirdness from this is that utils sometimes reach out to the
editor for cached versions of data rather than calling their own cached
methods. It's still an easier story to tell than what we had before.
### More defaults
We now have three and only three `abstract` methods for a `ShapeUtil`:
- `getDefaultProps` (renamed from `defaultProps`)
- `getBounds`,
- `component`
- `indicator`
Previously, we also had `getCenter` as an abstract method, though this
was usually just the middle of the bounds anyway.
### Editing bounds
This PR removes the concept of editingBounds. The viewport will no
longer animate to editing shapes.
### Active area manager
This PR also removes the active area manager, which was not being used
in the way we expected it to be.
### Dpr manager
This PR removes the dpr manager and uses a hook instead to update it
from React. This is one less runtime browser dependency in the app, one
less thing to document.
### Moving things around
This PR also continues to try to organize related methods and properties
in the editor.
### Change Type
- [x] `major` — Breaking change
### Release Notes
- [editor] renames `defaultProps` to `getDefaultProps`
- [editor] removes `outline`, `outlineSegments`, `handles`, `bounds`
- [editor] renames `renderBackground` to `backgroundComponent`
Removes `propsForNextShape` and replaces it with the new styles API.
Changes in here:
- New custom style example
- `setProp` is now `setStyle` and takes a `StyleProp` instead of a
string
- `Editor.props` and `Editor.opacity` are now `Editor.sharedStyles` and
`Editor.sharedOpacity`
- They return an object that flags mixed vs shared types instead of
using null to signal mixed types
- `Editor.styles` returns a `SharedStyleMap` - keyed on `StyleProp`
instead of `string`
- `StateNode.shapeType` is now the shape util rather than just a string.
This lets us pull the styles from the shape type directly.
- `color` is no longer a core part of the editor set on the shape
parent. Individual child shapes have to use color directly.
- `propsForNextShape` is now `stylesForNextShape`
- `InstanceRecordType` is created at runtime in the same way
`ShapeRecordType` is. This is so it can pull style validators out of
shape defs for `stylesForNextShape`
- Shape type are now defined by their props rather than having separate
validators & type defs
### Change Type
- [x] `major` — Breaking change
### Test Plan
1. Big time regression testing around styles!
2. Check UI works as intended for all shape/style/tool combos
- [x] Unit Tests
- [ ] End to end tests
### Release Notes
-
---------
Co-authored-by: Steve Ruiz <steveruizok@gmail.com>
This PR is a refactor / tidy up of some snapping logic.
- Fix a bug where the recursive call to `findAdjacentGaps` could lead to
a maximum call stack error
- Fixed an issue that caused handle snapping to expensively recompute
- Fixed a dependency from the snap manager to the line shape
### Change Type
- [x] `patch`
### Test Plan
Our snap tests are pretty thorough, they should work here.
### Release Notes
- [editor] fix bug in snapping
Removes the cached (but not really needed) local transform for shapes.
We almost never get the local transform except when getting the page
transform.
### Change Type
- [x] `major` — Breaking change
### Release Notes
- [editor] Remove `ShapeUtil.transform`
This diff adds a new property to `defineShape`: `tool`.
The tool prop allows shapes to bring a tool along with them as part of
their definition. E.g. the draw shape isn't much use without the draw
tool, so adding the draw shape to your app gives you the draw tool tool.
As part of this, i renamed the `shapeutils` folder to just `shapes`, and
moved a bunch of shape-specific tools from the tools folder into the
shapes folder. This more closely reflects how things will be once we
move our default shapes out of core for tldraw-zero.
### Change Type
- [x] `patch` — Bug fix
### Test Plan
Tested locally
### Release Notes
n/a
David Sheldrick